Back
This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:
You do not need to instruct a solicitor to bring a car finance mis-selling claim and to receive any compensation that is due without charge; however, there are many reasons why you may wish to do so.
By instructing Harcus Parker to manage your car finance claim, you will enjoy numerous benefits that would otherwise remain untapped were you to take a complaint to a lender yourself.
The FCA’s final rules, confirmed on 30 March 2026, provide for a lender-led scheme. Lenders assess agreements and calculate any compensation due under those rules. The scheme is currently partially suspended while the Upper Tribunal considers four legal challenges.
Given that lenders' actions are what caused mis-selling on such a scale over more than 17 years, it is entirely understandable that you may not trust the lenders who did not act in your best interests when you took out your motor finance agreement to do the right thing now.
In a report published on 3 November 2025, titled Car Finance Scandal: Addressing Redress, the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Fair Banking cited the complexity of the regulator’s proposed redress calculations as an aspect of the scheme that lenders could exploit to avoid paying consumers what they owe, along with various further observations as to why and how it felt the FCA had sided with lenders in its broader proposals.
Although the regulator would argue that it has designed its redress scheme to ensure that as many eligible consumers as possible receive compensation, it does not guarantee that each individual will receive the full amount they are owed based on their specific circumstances.
The final rules require lenders to take reasonable steps to trace consumers whom they must contact. That does not mean every former customer will receive a letter. Your lender may have difficulty finding you if you have changed address or name, or if records from an older agreement are incomplete.
If you receive an invitation to opt in, you will normally have six months to respond. Lenders’ duties differ according to whether you have already complained, the features of your agreement and whether an exclusion applies. The partial suspension also affects when some communications must be sent. The FCA encourages consumers who think they may have a claim to complain now, rather than wait to be contacted.
Under the final rules, consumers who have neither complained nor been contacted can complain up to 31 August 2027. That date may change following the Upper Tribunal proceedings. A deadline in a letter you receive may be earlier, so it is important to check and respond to correspondence promptly.
The final compensation calculation is complex. A solicitor can request the information needed to check that the lender has applied the rules correctly, including the relevant commission, APR adjustment, caps and compensatory interest. Representation cannot secure more through the scheme than its rules allow.
The primary purpose of instructing a solicitor is to receive the car finance mis-selling compensation you deserve from your lender. If a lender denies wrongdoing and disputes that mis-selling occurred, claims not to have any information about your historical agreement(s), or does not offer what we estimate and believe to be the correct amount of redress, a solicitor can challenge those decisions and directions on your behalf.
That does not mean that a solicitor will be able to achieve a better outcome through the redress scheme than what the regulator's rules dictate; however, they can hold your lender(s) to their terms and ensure they correctly follow the rules.
Instructing a solicitor to investigate your car finance claim may also enable you to bring a more substantial claim or open up avenues for alternative claims. Issues your solicitor may be able to investigate and assist you with include:
The FCA’s final estimate is an average of £829 per eligible agreement, including interest. Individual awards may be higher or lower, and some consumers have several eligible agreements. Instructing a solicitor does not guarantee a higher award.
At the same time, you may have paid commissions at such a level that it is worth your while seeking compensation through the courts instead of accepting what your lender or lenders offer you via the redress scheme, if that figure is lower than what a court would award.
In such circumstances, a solicitor will be able to analyse the evidence and act on your behalf in cases where it is deemed appropriate and in your best interests to opt out of the redress scheme and accept the inevitably longer and potentially riskier process of litigation.
The FCA has encouraged consumers to complain early. Existing complaints will be considered under the scheme rules if the scheme proceeds, and making a complaint now can help lenders identify the relevant agreements and keep your details up to date. During the partial suspension, lenders are not required to calculate or pay scheme compensation, so neither an early complaint nor professional representation guarantees an earlier payment.
Although you can bring your car finance claim yourself at no cost, doing so could create a significant administrative burden and hassle.
For example, if your lender fails to contact you during the redress scheme, or you decide to start a complaint before the redress scheme formally commences, you will need to:
The general complaint-handling pause ended on 31 May 2026. Under the partial suspension, lenders must still prepare for the scheme and respond to certain complainants whom they consider are not owed compensation. The response deadlines, exceptions and the FCA’s seven-week allowance are explained in our claim timing FAQ. Complaints wholly outside the scheme should proceed in the usual way.
In contrast, should you instruct a solicitor to bring your claim, you do not need to do so much as even to find your paperwork. They can manage the entire process on your behalf, from identifying your previous car finance agreements and submitting your claim(s) to your lender(s) to making all necessary representations and distributing your redress.
In addition to managing your actual claim, dealing with bank correspondence and legalese can be daunting, especially if your lender proves uncooperative and challenging to work with.
Even if you choose not to complain directly and wait for the redress scheme to begin, you will still have to engage with the scheme itself and communicate with your lender(s) about issues such as whether you wish to ‘opt-in’ to the scheme and make a complaint or whether you wish to ‘opt-out’ if you have already made a complaint.
Instructing a solicitor to bring your claim removes all of this stress from you and allows a team of experts to do the work and get your redress for you.
You can complain directly to your lender for free. If you instruct Harcus Parker, there are no upfront costs and a success fee is deducted from any compensation, subject to the agreed terms and applicable caps. Our fees FAQ explains the charges, including the reserved right to charge £75 plus VAT per claim if you cancel after 14 days. Any proposed court proceedings require separate advice about costs, delay and risk.
Scheme payments are not expected before 2027. The Upper Tribunal hearings are provisionally listed for 14–18 December 2026 or 16–26 February 2027, with judgment to follow. The timetable depends on the outcome and any appeal; a revised scheme could cause further delays.
You can check your eligibility and register your claim here.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.