If you took out a PCP or HP car, van, motorhome, or motorbike finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 in England, Scotland or Wales and used the vehicle mainly for personal use, you may be eligible to claim:
Find out more information on eligibility here.
If your claim is successful, we will charge:
There are no upfront costs. If you do choose to cancel your claim with us after 14 days, we reserve the right to charge you a cancellation fee of £75 + VAT per claim as a contribution to the time spent and expenses incurred regarding your claim.
Harcus Parker is a London-based litigation firm which is recognised for its specialism in complex, large-scale group actions. By choosing Harcus Parker, you benefit from:
Certainty. Although the scheme rules require lenders to take reasonable steps to trace their customers, there is no certainty that your lender will locate you, particularly if you have moved or changed your name, or your agreement concluded more than six years ago and records have been destroyed. The rules also require you to respond. If your lender invites you to join the scheme, you will normally have six months to reply, and if you do not reply you may receive nothing. If your lender does not contact you at all, you can complain up to 31 August 2027, although that date may change depending on the outcome of the Upper Tribunal proceedings.
Speed. The FCA has stated that if consumers have complained before the commencement of the redress scheme, they are likely to receive redress sooner.
Less hassle. You do not need your old paperwork. We manage the entire process for you, using technology to progress your claim efficiently, from identifying your claims and submitting them to the defendants, to making all necessary representations, to distributing compensation if you are entitled to it.
Verification and accountability. The calculation methodology is complex. We can check the defendants’ calculations and require the defendants to disclose the information on which they are based to ensure that you receive the correct amount of redress. The redress scheme is lender-led. You may not trust lenders, who acted against your interests in the first place and who are in charge of running the scheme, to do the right thing now.
Legal expertise. We have in-depth knowledge of the laws and regulations surrounding motor finance claims.
Potentially stronger claims and alternative claims. If a lender denies wrongdoing, claims not to have information or does not offer what we estimate to be the correct amount of compensation, we can challenge their decision. Note that we are not saying that we will achieve a better result through the redress scheme than the redress scheme rules dictate. We can, however, hold the defendants to its terms. Issues we may be able to assist with include:
A risk-free service. No upfront costs. Most clients will pay between 28-30% (plus VAT) of their compensation to Harcus Parker, unless in your case we agree that the litigation route is advisable. For a full explanation of our fees, click here. Note that it is possible to claim yourself without charge.
Multiple claims. We can handle all your claims for you, even if you borrowed from multiple lenders, and even if some of your agreements date back to as long ago as 2007, we could find and present evidence for you to substantiate a claim.
A stress-free service. Dealing with bank correspondence and legalese can be daunting. Our experienced team and technology can handle it all for you. Even though the FCA has attempted to create as simple and straightforward a scheme as possible, you will still have to engage with it and make decisions, including whether to accept or challenge any offer you receive. The scheme is currently partially suspended while the Upper Tribunal considers four legal challenges, and redress payments are not expected before 2027.
The FCA accepts (as we believe is inevitable) that not everyone will receive correspondence from their lender and has encouraged consumers to complain if they can. It has pointed out that to make a claim yourself without charge you will need to track down your lender and see if you can find a copy of your finance agreements. The FCA has suggested that you could try checking old bank statements, as the lender should be named there; you can ask the dealer from which you purchased the vehicle for details; or, if the agreement was within the last six years, you can check your own credit file. The FCA points out that the Information Commissioner’s Office (‘ICO’) has information on how to obtain one’s credit file here. The ICO gives guidance as to how to make a Data Subject Access Request (‘DSAR’) and also notes that most of the credit checking agencies have a facility for people to access their own file without making a formal DSAR. Or we can help.
The practices which give rise to motor finance claims were current between 2007 and 2021 in the case of discretionary commissions (the FCA only banned discretionary commission arrangements in January 2021 after a review that began in 2017) and to 1 November 2024 in the case of the practices of charging very high undisclosed fixed commissions and failing to disclose a tied commercial relationship between dealership and lender which gave the lender exclusivity or a right of first refusal.
In January 2024, the FCA began a major investigation into hidden commissions in motor finance agreements. As a result, motor finance complaint handling was paused until 31 May 2026, and many consumers are now coming forward to claim back the money they overpaid. On 30 March 2026, the FCA confirmed the details of an industry-wide redress scheme.
The scheme is currently partially suspended. Four parties are challenging it at the Upper Tribunal: the advocacy group Consumer Voice, and three lenders, Mercedes-Benz Financial Services, Volkswagen Financial Services and Crédit Agricole Auto Finance. The Tribunal will hear those challenges between 16 February and 3 March 2027, with judgment expected in the months that follow. The FCA has said that redress payments will not begin before 2027 and has cautioned that they could be delayed to 2028 or beyond if the scheme is quashed.
At this stage, it is hard to estimate what claims may be worth, and we stress that not all claims will automatically succeed. All claims will turn on their own facts.
If you are entitled to compensation, the FCA has stated that it expects consumers to receive an average of £829 (inclusive of interest), with many customers receiving more and a large number less. We do not, however, expect that most consumers will receive precisely the ‘average’ figure. Given the popularity of PCP / HP motor finance agreements, and since the claim period goes back to 2007, many clients will have more than one claim.
We note that in 2017, a survey conducted by the FCA based on evidence drawn from 16,000 contracts found the average overcharge as a consequence of Discretionary Commission Arrangements was £1,100 on a £10,000 loan. One reason why the FCA is now quoting a lower figure is that claims now extend beyond Discretionary Commission Arrangements to commission arrangements that were unfair for other reasons; another is that the final rules include an ‘APR adjustment’ and do not simply refund the overcharge. Most awards use the average of a consumer’s estimated loss and the commission paid to the broker. The scheme’s caps and compensatory interest rules also apply.
The value of your claim depends on factors including the size of your loan, the commission, the dates of your agreement and payments, and the scheme’s calculation rules.
Compensatory interest is calculated on a simple basis using the annual average Bank of England base rate plus one percentage point, subject to a minimum of 3% in any year and the rates specified in the scheme rules. For the commission repayment component, interest runs from the date you entered into the agreement; for the APR-adjustment component, it runs from the date of each relevant overpayment. Interest is calculated up to the date of the redress payment. The compensatory interest rate cannot be challenged within the scheme.
We understand that some of the proportionally highest commissions were charged on relatively small loans, so there may not always be a direct relationship between the value of the contract and the size of the claim.
Some lenders motivated dealers to increase your interest rate to earn commission, without telling you. These undisclosed arrangements, called Discretionary Commission Arrangements (DCAs) or Difference-in-Charge commissions (DICs), were banned by the FCA in January 2021. If you were affected, you may be entitled to compensation.
Other lenders paid excessively high levels of fixed commissions which affected the cost of your lending. The FCA has decided that the threshold above which redress should be paid is when the commission was equal to or greater than 39% of the total cost of credit and 10% of the loan.
And others had tied commercial relationships with dealerships which either gave them exclusivity or a right of first refusal. This practice also led to consumer detriment.
The redress scheme is currently partially suspended while the Upper Tribunal considers four legal challenges to it. The FCA has confirmed that redress payments will not begin before 2027.
While the suspension is in place, lenders do not have to calculate or pay compensation. They must still identify relevant complaints and agreements, and they must tell consumers who have complained if they are not owed compensation under the scheme, by:
Consumers who complain after the relevant complaint cut-off date above and are not owed compensation should receive a response within five months of their complaint. The FCA has said it will not treat a lender as non-compliant provided it responds within seven weeks of the relevant deadline, so in practice these dates may run later.
The response deadlines above do not apply where your lender considers your complaint was out of time when the scheme was made, or where it relies on the exception for a contractual tie involving visible links between the lender, manufacturer and franchised dealer. These issues form part of the legal challenges before the Upper Tribunal.
If the scheme proceeds, lenders will contact consumers who have not complained and invite them to join, and those consumers will have six months to respond. Consumers who have already complained will be contacted with a decision on whether they are owed compensation and will have a month to accept or challenge any offer.
We caveat all of this by observing that it seems likely to us that in the early days of the scheme there will be delays whilst the lenders’ administrative processes are tested and until the substantial backlog of cases that have been awaiting a final response since January 2024 are cleared. Whilst we expect routine complaints to be resolved quickly (and the redress scheme has been designed with the aim of ensuring that most complaints are treated as routine) complex cases will take longer, especially in cases where we may require further details from you.
Complaints that sit wholly outside of the FCA redress scheme can proceed as normal.
Mis-selling is something of a misnomer. These claims arise from the charging of hidden commissions that made motor finance more expensive than it should have been. The hidden nature of the commissions means that you cannot know if you have a valid claim without first obtaining disclosure of what commissions, if any, and what type of commissions your dealership received from your lender.
You may have a valid claim if:
As part of instructing us, we will write to your lender and make enquiries as to the full circumstances of your agreement.
Because these are claims concerning undisclosed commissions, you cannot know (and nor can anyone tell you) whether you have a valid claim without first checking with your lender.
Under the FCA’s redress scheme rules, lenders will have to write to consumers whose agreements fall within the scheme, and to those who have already complained. Those obligations are currently affected by the partial suspension of the scheme, so many consumers may not hear from their lender until the Upper Tribunal proceedings conclude.
We anticipate that many consumers may miss out though. Consumers may not receive correspondence informing them they have a claim; others may miss out because they may have to take an active step to receive compensation.
The FCA has suggested that consumers should not delay in making a complaint if they consider they are eligible and says that early complaints will be resolved sooner than later complaints.
Although a model letter published on the FCA’s website suggests consumers should provide lenders only with their current and past addresses and registration number, that of course assumes that the consumer knows who their lender is. The FCA has previously stated that to make a claim yourself without charge you will need to check to see if you can find a copy of your finance agreements. You could try checking old bank statements, as the lender should be named there; you can ask the dealer from which you purchased the vehicle for details; or, if the agreement was within the last six years, you can check your own credit file. The FCA points out that the Information Commissioner’s Office (‘ICO’) has information on how to obtain one’s credit file here. The ICO gives guidance as to how to make a Data Subject Access Request (‘DSAR’) and also notes that most of the credit checking agencies have a facility for people to access their own file without making a formal DSAR.
Or we can do this for you.
A DCA is a commission structure through which the dealer could set or influence the interest rate offered to the customer, with their commission increasing if a higher rate was agreed. This in our view created a conflict of interest, as dealers were motivated to encourage customers to agree to higher rates. We discuss the legal and regulatory implications of DCAs below.
To put this another way – what is wrong with discretionary commissions (DCAs)? In answering this question below, we are not giving legal advice but are providing our view on the situation in general. Nor are we saying that all claims will succeed. Under the FCA’s final redress scheme, inadequate disclosure of a discretionary commission arrangement, high commission or a relevant contractual tie may give rise to redress, subject to the scheme’s eligibility requirements, exceptions and exclusions. Falling within one of those categories does not automatically guarantee compensation. Each claim will turn on its own facts.
With these caveats, the essence of these claims is that the lender should take responsibility for having established a scheme of payment of commissions which disadvantages the customer.
If a secret ‘Difference In Charge’ commission, or 'Discretionary Commission Arrangement' was associated with a consumer’s credit agreement, parallel and overlapping claims in law / regulatory complaints arise.
There are two routes to liability in relation to DCAs, now that the Supreme Court has confirmed, in its judgment handed down on 1 August 2025 in Hopcraft, Johnson and Wrench that there is no claim for breach of fiduciary / disinterested duties.
The Judge in R (Clydesdale Financial Services Ltd) v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd [2024] EWHC 3237 (Admin) quotes a decision of the Financial Ombudsman:
The discretionary commission model Barclays PF used in Miss L's case, created an inherent conflict between the interests of the Broker and the interests of Miss L, as it gave the Broker an incentive to set a higher interest rate than Barclays PF would have accepted so that the Broker could receive more commission.
In introducing and operating the discretionary commission arrangement with the Broker on the terms it did, Barclays PF acted contrary to the guidance at CONC 4.5.2G and failed to have due regard to Miss L's interests and treat her fairly as required by Principle 6 of the Financial Conduct Authority's ("FCA") Principles for Businesses (the "Principles").
This describes the lender’s conduct by reference to the Principles for Businesses and guidance (denoted by ‘G’). The FCA can take action for breaches of applicable Principles and rules. Guidance informs how those requirements apply, but is distinct from a binding rule. In order to bring a claim under s138D of FSMA, a consumer needs to show a breach of a ‘rule’ (denoted by ‘R’) in the Handbook.
In the FCA’s published findings in its investigation of the motor finance sector (published in March 2019), the FCA found that the way in which commission arrangements operate might be leading to consumer harm on a potentially significant scale (see the FCA Review Findings, Executive Summary, p.4).
In the paragraphs below, we pick through the various ways in which the lenders’ conduct in a paradigm motor finance case offends against the regulatory framework in which they were supposed to operate.
PRIN requires lenders and their agents to adhere to eleven principles of business (the ‘Principles’) in their dealings with consumers. By secretly operating a discretionary commission model, to a consumer’s detriment, a lender will be taken knowingly to have incentivised the dealership to act against consumers’ best interests. It will therefore have breached the Principles in at least the following ways.
It will have:
The provisions below must be considered in the form that applied when the relevant conduct occurred. In particular, the additional disclosure requirement in CONC 4.5.3AR came into force on 28 January 2021 and should not be applied retrospectively to earlier sales. The relevant provisions include:
Breaches of rules set out in CONC give rise (subject to the limited exceptions listed in Schedule 50) to claims for statutory duty pursuant to section 138D of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.
In addition, all of the relevant senior staff who from time to time had managerial responsibility for motor finance were arguably personally in breach of COCON 2.2.3[R]:
SC3: You must take reasonable steps to ensure that any delegation of your responsibilities is to an appropriate person and that you oversee the discharge of the delegated responsibility effectively.
Where the relevant commission arrangements were not disclosed, a potential claim under section 138D requires assessment of the applicable actionable rule, the defendant’s responsibility and the loss caused by any breach. The FCA has now confirmed its final redress scheme in Policy Statement PS26/3. Eligibility and compensation under that scheme must be assessed under its rules, including its unfair-relationship framework and exclusions, and the scheme is currently partially suspended pending legal challenges.
S.140A sets out what factors a court might consider when seeking to determine whether the relationship between the creditor and the debtor is fair, in relation to a credit agreement:
Under section 140B the court can require:
Guidance illustrating how the court will interpret section 140A was provided in the Supreme Court decision in Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Limited [2014] UKSC 61 WLR 4222. The key to the unfairness in that case was the degree of inequality of knowledge between the creditor and debtor. Considerations listed in Plevin as being relevant to the fairness in the relationship include: ‘the characteristics of the borrower, her sophistication or vulnerability, the facts which she could reasonably be expected to know or assume, the range of choices available to her, and the degree to which the creditor was or should have been aware of these matters’.
Here, in DCA cases, the factors which confirm that the relationship was unfair are:
In the Johnson case, the factors that pointed to unfairness included the type of commission, the size of the commission and the tied commercial relationship between dealership and lender. These factors may apply to cases that did not involve a DCA, but which involved a lending arrangement which was arguable otherwise unfair.
The ‘things done or not done’ for the purpose of proving the jurisdictional requirement in respect of causation under s.140A(1)(c) were the non-disclosure by the lender or that by the dealer, on the basis that, in fixing the interest rate, the dealer was acting on behalf of the lender.
If you need assistance, our team is here to help. Contact us via info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and one of our team will be in touch.
We explain why it is worth making a car finance claim here.
Yes. It is important for us to stress that if you do nothing you may be contacted by your lender, or you can proactively make a car finance claim yourself by using free template letters available from trusted sites like Resolver and MoneySavingExpert, or by following the advice of the FCA by using its template letter and applying to your lender, perhaps having first checked to see if you can find a copy of your finance agreements, looked through old bank statements, asked the dealer from which you purchased the vehicle for details, or, if the agreement was within the last six years, checked your own credit file.
But whilst it is possible to go it alone, mis-sold car finance claims could (despite the FCA’s best efforts) become complex if:
Choosing a legal firm like Harcus Parker means you are backed by a team of financial claims experts with experience in handling complex claims. We manage the whole process, from verifying your eligibility to reviewing and challenging lenders’ decisions and calculations, so you do not have to.
With us, claiming is hassle-free and comes without an upfront fee, noting that you may receive compensation in any event, that you can act for yourself for free, and that instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you will receive compensation or that you have a valid claim.
You can find out more about the FCA’s redress scheme here.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.