Back

Car finance cost
12 January 2026

6 risks of accepting your lender’s first compensation offer

Important update: The FCA redress scheme is partially suspended

This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:

  • The redress scheme is partially suspended: The Upper Tribunal will hear four challenges to the scheme between 16 February and 3 March 2027. Lenders are not currently required to calculate or pay redress, and payments are not expected to begin until 2027 at the earliest. Your lender should write to you if you have already complained and you are not owed compensation, although the FCA says some consumers may not be told until the legal process concludes.
  • Revised eligibility estimate: The FCA now estimates that 12.1 million agreements are eligible for compensation, down from the 14.2 million estimated in its 2025 consultation.
  • Increased compensation estimate: The FCA now anticipates average redress payouts of £829 per mis-sold agreement.
  • Compensatory interest changes: The regulator has introduced a minimum 3% floor for compensatory interest; however, the rate applied to awards within the redress scheme can no longer be challenged.
  • You may not hear from your lender: If the scheme proceeds, contact obligations also cover certain consumers who have not complained, including those potentially owed compensation and certain time-barred cases. If you do not hear from your lender, you could still have a valid claim but risk missing out entirely.

The FCA published its final motor finance redress scheme rules on 30 March 2026. The scheme is now partially suspended while legal challenges are considered, so lenders are not currently required to calculate or pay scheme redress. If you receive an offer, check whether it is made under the scheme or is a separate voluntary settlement.

A prompt offer may appear attractive if you want certainty. The amount, calculation and settlement terms still need checking. However, an early settlement offer made under the final scheme rules must be at least the maximum redress available under the scheme; it is not simply a discounted opening bid.

Here are six risks to consider before accepting your lender’s first—or any—compensation offer without seeking legal advice.

1. A compensation offer may reflect only what the redress scheme covers

The final scheme addresses specified commission-related unfairness. It does not resolve every possible issue arising from buying and financing a vehicle.

If you accept an offer from a lender that is based on the regulator’s methodology, you may be accepting an outcome that does not reflect other potential losses or claim types, such as irresponsible lending issues or mis-sold add-ons such as GAP insurance, which sit outside the FCA’s analysis.

Whether you have any separate claim, and what it might be worth, depends on its legal basis, the evidence, time limits and any settlement terms. A separate claim does not guarantee additional compensation, and the same loss cannot be recovered twice.

Instructing a solicitor may help you assess an offer and identify any separate claims. You can also use the FCA scheme yourself without paying a representative.

2. Early scheme offers have specific safeguards

Under the final rules, a lender may make an early settlement offer as a provisional redress decision. It must be able to demonstrate that the offer is at least the maximum redress available to you under the scheme, explain the amount and provide the required breakdown and information about your rights.

Check the basis of any early offer, particularly during the partial suspension. An offer outside the formal scheme may have different terms. In either case, understand what claims you would settle, what rights you would give up and whether unrelated claims are preserved.

3. Settlement terms may limit your options later

The settlement wording matters as well as the amount offered.

Offers presented and accepted on ‘full and final settlement’ terms may limit your ability to pursue a court claim later in relation to the matters covered by the settlement wording, depending on the precise wording you accept.

At a minimum, you should ensure you understand:

  • what specific claims are being settled;
  • whether you are being asked to waive any rights; and
  • whether the wording preserves your ability to pursue other issues, such as irresponsible lending concerns or mis-sold add-ons.

If you are uncertain, consider seeking legal advice.

4. The redress calculation may be difficult for you to verify

The final scheme is administered by lenders, which hold the agreement and commission information and are responsible for assessing eligibility, calculating redress and explaining their decisions. Their duties to calculate and pay redress are currently suspended.

When you receive a decision or offer, check the agreement details, commission information, assumptions, calculation and compensatory interest. The final rules require lenders to explain their decisions. Ask for clarification if the information provided does not let you understand the outcome, and follow the applicable challenge process and deadlines stated in the letter.

This is a common structural risk in mass redress exercises and may be particularly prevalent in motor finance, given that agreements entered into as long ago as April 2007 may be eligible for compensation.

5. Compensatory interest may not match your expectations

You may assume that your compensatory interest award will be substantial, particularly for older agreements and if you have previously seen advertising from law firms and claims management companies that were basing compensation estimates on highly optimistic figures.

There are two points to consider here:

  • The final compensatory interest rules use annual average Bank of England base rate plus one percentage point, subject to a minimum 3%, calculated on a simple basis using the scheme’s specified rates.
  • You cannot challenge that scheme interest rate or obtain a higher rate within the scheme by showing that you borrowed elsewhere at a higher rate. Any separate consequential-loss claim needs its own legal and evidential assessment.

Check that interest has been calculated correctly, including the amount, dates and applicable rates. The commission-based component accrues interest from the start of the agreement; the APR-adjustment component accrues interest from the individual overpayments. Interest runs to payment of redress. A calculation error can be queried even though the prescribed scheme interest rate cannot be challenged.

6. You may receive less cash than the headline figure

The final rules allow redress to be set off against arrears or defaults on the motor finance agreement for which redress is owed. They do not allow scheme redress to be applied to any unrelated debt you happen to owe the same lender.

You can object to set-off where it would be unfair because the relevant arrears or default is subject to an unresolved dispute, complaint or legal claim, or because you can demonstrate arrears on priority debts. Provide evidence and follow the process explained by your lender.

This means that:

  • you may receive a reduced, or no, cash payment even if redress is due; and
  • a lender may reduce debt on the relevant agreement instead of paying that part of the redress in cash, subject to the scheme’s protections.

Set-off is not automatically a ‘bad’ solution, particularly if you are currently in arrears with a lender against whom you have a valid motor finance mis-selling claim, but it changes what you will actually receive and how you should evaluate any offer.

For an ongoing agreement without undisputed arrears or defaults, the lender may offer to apply redress against the outstanding principal balance, but it needs your consent.

What to do before you accept a compensation offer

If you receive a compensation offer from your lender, you should take the time to understand both what you are being offered and what you are being asked to give up.

At a minimum, you should consider doing the following:

  • Ask what the offer is: you may receive various communications from your lender, including those asking whether you wish to opt in to the redress scheme or not, as well as early or full and final settlement offers.
  • Request a clear breakdown: if not already provided, ask how the lender calculated the redress offer, what assumptions it used, and how compensatory interest was applied.
  • Check for set-off: establish whether redress would reduce arrears or the balance on the agreement concerned, whether consent is needed and whether you have grounds to object.
  • Look beyond commission: consider whether you wish to explore potential additional claims that will merit analysis outside of the redress scheme.
  • Take advice: speak to a solicitor if you are unsure about what to do or before agreeing to any ‘full and final’ settlement offer.

Register your motor finance claim with Harcus Parker and let us help you

The final scheme offers a free route to commission-related redress. A solicitor can help you understand an offer, check the calculation and settlement terms, and assess any separate claims outside the scheme. Representation involves fees and does not guarantee a larger award.

Register your car finance claim with Harcus Parker here, and we can assist with your claim, review any compensation offers you receive, and assess your circumstances to identify potential additional claims.

We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.