Back

Tribunal logo big 1
08 July 2026

Court of Appeal ruling clears way for motor finance group actions

Important update: The FCA redress scheme is partially suspended

This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:

  • The redress scheme is partially suspended: The Upper Tribunal will hear four challenges to the scheme between 16 February and 3 March 2027. Lenders are not currently required to calculate or pay redress, and payments are not expected to begin until 2027 at the earliest. Your lender should write to you if you have already complained and you are not owed compensation, although the FCA says some consumers may not be told until the legal process concludes.
  • Revised eligibility estimate: The FCA now estimates that 12.1 million agreements are eligible for compensation, down from the 14.2 million estimated in its 2025 consultation.
  • Increased compensation estimate: The FCA now anticipates average redress payouts of £829 per mis-sold agreement.
  • Compensatory interest changes: The regulator has introduced a minimum 3% floor for compensatory interest; however, the rate applied to awards within the redress scheme can no longer be challenged.
  • You may not hear from your lender: If the scheme proceeds, contact obligations also cover certain consumers who have not complained, including those potentially owed compensation and certain time-barred cases. If you do not hear from your lender, you could still have a valid claim but risk missing out entirely.

On 30 June 2026, the Court of Appeal ruled that thousands of car finance mis-selling claims can be dealt with using omnibus claim forms, after upholding the High Court’s decision in Angel & Ors v Black Horse Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 490. The Court of Appeal had heard the appeal on 22 April 2026.

The original decision, handed down on 4 March 2025, ruled that almost 6,000 car finance mis-selling claimants could proceed using omnibus forms against eight defendants, motor finance lenders Black Horse, BMW Financial Services, Stellantis Financial Services, Aldermore Bank, Close Brothers, Startline Motor Finance, MotoNovo Finance and Volkswagen Financial Services. Volkswagen Financial Services is also one of the three lenders challenging the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) motor finance consumer redress scheme, which the Upper Tribunal has partially suspended pending the hearing of those challenges.

Omnibus claims now likely to proceed

As the Court of Appeal’s decision related to procedure rather than liability, Angel is unlikely to go to the Supreme Court, meaning that these omnibus claims will now likely proceed.

The Angel judgment, coupled with the likely delay of redress scheme compensation payments until mid-2027 at the earliest, may drive a significant volume of further omnibus claims against lenders. While the FCA maintains its redress scheme is the simplest route to compensation for consumers and the most efficient way for lenders to put things right, this extended wait, combined with a clear procedural path through the courts, may push thousands more consumers toward mass litigation, where law firms have sufficient client numbers to proceed.

It is potentially also relevant to this ruling that, in a letter to the Chair of the Treasury Committee dated 8 June 2026, FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi noted that some firms ‘said they want to resolve these [redress] liabilities now and they are exploring whether they can make settlement offers on complaints that would have been dealt with through the scheme if it were not for the legal challenges. This could include cases where there is strong evidence that commission arrangements were not properly disclosed’.

Court of Appeal Justice outlines reasoning in judgment

In his judgment in Black Horse Limited v Stuart Angel & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 831, Lord Justice Coulson wrote that the court must have regard to the ‘commercial reality’ that, citing the High Court ruling, ‘there is an imbalance of financial power between individual claimants and the defendants’, and that ‘it also suits the defendants for there to be separate claims because the stronger claims can be settled and the less strong claims can be run into the ground’.

Lord Justice Coulson continued: ‘That dictates that the most practical way in which the court can achieve at least a measure of justice for the claimants in this case is by efficiently case-managing their claims to a convenient disposal. The defendants’ opposition to that outcome is commercially understandable, but…ultimately unrealistic.’

The judge also wrote: ‘This case has achieved almost nothing in its three-and-a-half year lifetime, save to run up extravagant costs. This too was the subject of adverse comment by the High Court judge. Apparently, the claimants’ costs of the appeal before him were £1.3 million. The claimants have provided no information as to their costs of the appeal to this court, but it is safe to assume that a similar order of costs has been incurred. Since there are eight defendants and they have chosen to put in five separate skeleton arguments, and instruct separate counsel, I imagine that their costs are at least the same as the claimants, if not higher. Such a level of costs is insupportable, particularly given that the individual claims in this case are likely to be modest (something in the region of £1,000 each).’

In dismissing the appeal and maintaining the orders of the High Court judge, Lord Justice Coulson remitted the matter to Birmingham County Court for further directions. The judge also added that he was ‘acutely aware that the claims in this appeal are, in some respects, the tip of an iceberg and that the court service, and Birmingham County Court in particular, are currently inundated with single claim forms with thousands of claimants. I do not underestimate the huge increase in workload that such multi-claimant claims engender.’

Is there a benefit to pursuing motor finance redress through litigation?

Given the partial suspension of the regulator’s redress scheme and the ongoing delays in compensation payments, consumers should consider all their options for pursuing complaints against their lenders.

While it costs nothing to complain to your lender directly and to receive compensation from the FCA redress scheme, assuming it proceeds in 2027, there may be several benefits to instructing a professional representative. For example, a solicitor may identify grounds to bring additional claims, such as for mis-sold GAP insurance and irresponsible lending, depending on your circumstances and the facts surrounding your broader motor finance transaction.

Register your claim with Harcus Parker

In addition to the benefits already outlined, a solicitor can also verify your claim and lenders' redress calculations to ensure that you receive everything you should and that lenders have applied the redress scheme rules correctly. By handling cases on an individual basis rather than within mass litigation, we can ensure your unique circumstances are fully evaluated.

Register your claim with Harcus Parker here.

We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.