Back

Car finance cost
28 October 2026

How will lenders decide whether your car finance commission was ‘high’?

Under the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) final redress rules, set out in Policy Statement PS26/3 on 30 March 2026, commission payable is considered ‘high’ if it was at least:

  • 39% of the total cost of credit; and
  • 10% of the total borrowed.

If that commission was not properly disclosed to you, your relationship with your lender is presumed to have been unfair. The FCA estimated in PS26/3 that inadequately disclosed high commission was present in 8.4% of motor finance agreements across the market between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024.

This test matters now because lenders are already applying it. Although the regulator’s redress scheme is partially suspended while the four legal challenges to it wait to be heard by the Upper Tribunal between 16 February and 3 March 2027, lenders must still tell consumers who have already complained if they are not owed compensation, with the first deadlines for doing so falling on 18 November 2026 and 18 January 2027. Whether your agreement included commission that crossed these thresholds is one of the questions behind your lender’s decision on whether you are owed compensation, and it turns on three figures, one of which is unlikely to appear anywhere in your paperwork.

What counts as commission?

The rules themselves, which call an arrangement meeting both thresholds a ‘high commission arrangement’, are set out in the FCA Handbook, in CONRED 5 for agreements entered into from 1 April 2014 and in CONRED 6 for earlier agreements.

Both CONRED 5 and CONRED 6 outline that:

‘Commission’ means any commission, fee or other financial consideration or remuneration payable (directly or indirectly) by a lender to a credit broker in connection with the entering into of a specific motor finance agreement.

The ‘total amount of commission’ is further defined as:

…the sum of all commission payable in connection with the entering into of a specific motor finance agreement.

This definition means that if a broker was paid under more than one arrangement, the commission under each of them counts towards the total. For example, if your agreement involved both a discretionary commission arrangement (DCA) and a fixed commission, both would be added together. Payments your broker may have received for hitting volume or sales targets across many agreements do not count under these specific rules. Where a dealer was paid upfront, in what are sometimes called advance commissions, the commission on your agreement still counts if it was set off against that payment.

Even where both thresholds are met, a high commission arrangement does not count under the scheme if the total commission was £120 or less for an agreement entered into before 1 April 2014, or £150 or less from that date, or if the APR on the agreement was 0%, although your lender must be able to evidence this. As commission must also be at least 10% of the amount borrowed, the £120 and £150 limits can only make a difference where you borrowed £1,200 or less before 1 April 2014, or £1,500 or less from that date. Those smaller agreements are where, as we have previously examined, lower-income consumers may miss out.

How will lenders calculate the 39%?

Two divisions decide it.

  • The first divides your total commission by your total cost of credit, which the rules call the total charge for credit and define as ‘the true cost to the borrower of the credit’, calculated under the FCA’s own rules. The FCA describes it more simply as ‘the interest and charges for your loan’.
  • The second divides the same commission by the amount you borrowed, which the rules call the total amount of credit, or the sums made available to you under the agreement.

Your credit agreement, if you still have it, is likely to show how much you borrowed and what you paid in interest and fees. What that is unlikely to detail is the commission, which is what you may need to ask your lender for.

Illustrative example

In a hypothetical motor finance agreement where a car dealer arranged a loan of £10,000, with a total cost of credit of £2,500, and received £1,000 in commission:

  • £1,000 is 40% of the £2,500 total cost of credit, meeting the first threshold; and
  • £1,000 is 10% of the £10,000 borrowed, meeting the second.

This agreement would be considered as having a high commission arrangement. If the cost of credit was £2,600 instead, for example if a £100 fee had been counted within it, the same £1,000 would be 38.5% of the total cost of credit and the agreement would fall short. Agreements that match this example may prove contentious, for two reasons:

  • they would have qualified under the 35% threshold the regulator consulted on in Consultation Paper CP25/27; and
  • the difference between crossing the threshold and falling short could be little more than how a lender has counted a single fee or payment.

The two thresholds can also pull in different directions. On a cheaper loan, even a modest commission can be a large share of the total cost of credit. A £600 commission on a £10,000 loan with interest and charges totalling £1,500 is 40% of the total cost of credit, but only 6% of the amount borrowed, so would not qualify.

Why did the FCA settle on 39%?

The FCA described the change from 35% in CP25/27 to 39% in PS26/3 as having ‘modestly raised’ the threshold. On page 15 of PS26/3, the regulator explains that:

‘Further analysis confirms that higher commissions are associated with higher borrowing costs and so there are circumstances where the size of the commission should be disclosed. However, this analysis has not identified a specific threshold.

We are instead using an approach that identifies cases that lie significantly beyond market norms. We have used our judgement to define high commission as agreements with commission rates above 85% of all cases.’

The regulator’s updated economic analysis on page 30 of PS26/3 said it found that, on average, each £1 of broker commission was associated with a 79p increase in the consumer’s total cost of credit. The FCA is careful to state this does not establish a causal link.

The 39% threshold is contested by Volkswagen Financial Services and CA Auto Finance UK.

In our view, a fixed threshold as implemented by the regulator makes verifying the accuracy of a lender’s calculations even more vital.

Where could lender calculations go wrong?

Our guide on what to do if your lender says you are not owed compensation covers some of the broader weaknesses that the regulator found when it assessed lenders’ plans for implementing the redress scheme earlier in 2026. For the high commission test itself, the following points should be checked.

All the commission

The total should include all commission payable for your agreement, including where it was split between more than one broker or paid indirectly through another company in the lender’s group, or, as the FCA told lenders in guidance updated on 19 October 2026, by the manufacturer on the lender’s behalf.

Commission that was payable

The rules say that your agreement should be assessed on what the broker was entitled to receive. A lender may rely on records that state what commission it actually paid, but only where those records are a reasonable proxy.

The total cost of credit

This must be calculated as detailed in the FCA’s final rules. The fees counted within your total cost of credit may be the difference between your agreement qualifying as a high commission arrangement or not.

More than one agreement for the same car

Where one vehicle purchase was financed by more than one agreement, the regulator’s rules require the lender to add the commission, the cost of credit and the total amount borrowed across all of them. Mr Johnson, whose case reached the Supreme Court, financed his car with both a hire purchase agreement and a personal loan from FirstRand Bank.

What if you were told about the commission?

It depends on what, specifically, you were told. For a high commission arrangement to be considered adequately disclosed, you must have been told, clearly and prominently and before you signed, both that commission was payable and how much it was, either in pounds or as a method of calculation that allowed you to understand its size. Being told simply that commission ‘may’ or ‘would’ be paid does not meet the standard for adequate disclosure.

However, such partial disclosure still may be relevant to your claim. Where a claim relates only to high commission and an agreement ended before 26 March 2020, the FCA says lenders can treat the case as out of time if they can show that it was clearly and prominently disclosed that commission was payable, even if you were not told the amount. Lenders relying on that exception do not have to meet the deadlines outlined earlier, because how the scheme identified out-of-time complaints is one of the issues to be determined by the Upper Tribunal. Should this exception remain following the legal challenges, your lender must tell you if you are not eligible for redress on this basis and explain why. You will retain the right to challenge that decision via escalation to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

If the scheme proceeds as published in PS26/3, lenders will also be able to try to rebut high commission claims by showing, supported by evidence from the time, that you could not have obtained a lower APR from another lender the dealer had an arrangement with.

What if the commission was very high?

The scheme sets a second test, with higher thresholds. Where commission was at least 50% of the total cost of credit and at least 22.5% of the amount borrowed, and your agreement also involved a DCA, a contractual tie, or both, you may receive all the commission paid, plus interest with no caps applied.

The FCA estimates that around 90,000 consumers fall into this group. The regulator has named this remedy the ‘Johnson remedy’ after the Supreme Court ruling in Johnson, where the court found that a commission of 25% of the amount borrowed and 55% of the total cost of credit was a ‘powerful indication’ that the relationship between Mr Johnson and the lender was unfair.

Where high commission is the only unfair feature, redress is instead calculated as the average of an estimated loss and the commission paid, plus interest. The FCA calls this the hybrid remedy, and compensation may be capped in such cases. The regulator’s rules use the same APR adjustments it applies to DCA cases as the measure of loss here. We explain how this works in greater detail in our guide to how much car finance compensation you may receive.

How can you check your agreement yourself?

Find your agreement

Our guide to finding your old car finance agreements may help you identify who your lenders were if you choose to complain yourself.

Ask your lender for the commission figure

Your lender should be able to tell you how much commission was payable to the dealer on your agreement, and how it was categorised.

Do the two divisions

Divide the commission figure by the total cost of credit and then by the total amount borrowed. If either figure sits close to 39% or 10%, the detail and methodology of your lender’s calculation matters.

Ask for your lender’s figures

If your lender tells you that you are not owed compensation, ask them which figures they used for your commission, cost of credit and amount borrowed. You will usually have one month to respond to your lender’s decision. If you then remain dissatisfied with your lender’s response or decision, you can refer the decision to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which will consider whether your lender followed the scheme rules correctly.

Register your motor finance claim with Harcus Parker

You do not need to instruct a professional representative, such as a solicitor, a law firm or a claims management company, for your car finance claim. You can complain directly to your lender and receive any compensation you are owed yourself and at no cost.

If you choose to instruct us to manage your motor finance claim, we can:

  • identify your motor finance agreements back to 6 April 2007, including instances where you used more than one agreement to finance the same vehicle;
  • request disclosure of the commission payable on each agreement and how your lender categorised it;
  • check your lender’s calculations against the scheme rules and challenge them where we consider them wrong; and
  • investigate whether you may have claims that fall outside the scheme.

Instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you will receive more compensation or that you have a valid claim.

You can check your eligibility and register your car finance claim with Harcus Parker here.

We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.