Back

Car finance cost
16 October 2026

MotoNovo more than doubles motor finance redress charge

MotoNovo Finance Limited has more than doubled its annual charge for motor finance redress, from £60.6 million to £153.2 million. This figure was detailed in the company’s most recent accounts for the year to 30 June 2026, filed at Companies House on 28 September 2026, and reported by City AM on 30 September 2026. The charge comprises £147.8 million to pay compensation to affected consumers and a further £5.4 million for operational costs, including legal fees, complaint handling and preparing for the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) redress scheme.

MotoNovo Finance Limited’s owner, Aldermore Group, was put up for sale by its parent, South Africa-based FirstRand, in April 2026. FirstRand announced it would exit the UK market at the same time as it increased its group provision by £510 million to £750 million and called the regulator’s redress scheme ‘disproportionate and unfair’, although it declined to challenge it.

How does MotoNovo’s charge relate to FirstRand’s provision?

MotoNovo has provided motor finance through two different companies.

  • Agreements entered into before May 2019 were provided by FirstRand Bank Limited’s London branch, trading as MotoNovo Finance. This was the lender involved in the landmark Johnson test case decided by the Supreme Court in August 2025.
  • Agreements entered into since May 2019, when MotoNovo was integrated into Aldermore, have been provided by MotoNovo Finance Limited.

This means that MotoNovo’s £153.2 million charge is included in FirstRand’s group provision, which stood at £756.4 million at 30 June 2026. Of that £756.4 million, £524.6 million relates to what FirstRand describes as its MotoNovo ‘back book’ of older agreements, with the remaining £231.8 million relating to its UK operations, of which £220.3 million sits with MotoNovo Finance Limited.

Do FirstRand’s figures tell us anything about agreements made after the DCA ban?

The FCA banned discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs) on 28 January 2021, although data shared by the regulator on page 162 of its redress scheme consultation show that their use declined considerably before this date. The date of the DCA ban means that any agreements eligible for compensation under the regulator’s redress scheme entered into after that date will involve either a high commission, which the FCA defines in its final rules as commission comprising at least 39% of the total cost of credit and at least 10% of the total loan amount, or a contractual tie, in either case not adequately disclosed.

In April 2026, FirstRand told its shareholders that ‘a considerably larger portion than expected’ of its £510 million increase was ‘for the business written post the FCA’s regulatory changes in 2021’.

FirstRand does not accept the regulator’s approach to deciding whether its customers were treated unfairly. It has argued that the regulator treats the non-disclosure of a DCA, a contractual tie or a high commission as ‘unsubstantiated standalone factors’ that each make a relationship unfair, when the Supreme Court said that several factors must be weighed case by case.

In our view, the figures remain significant. FirstRand’s provision is its own estimate of how the scheme will apply to MotoNovo customers, and on that estimate more of the April increase than it expected relates to agreements entered into after DCAs were banned. That suggests to us that undisclosed commission, whether through high commission or ties, continued to affect MotoNovo customers after January 2021.

What has MotoNovo said about Johnson?

City AM reported that MotoNovo’s recently published accounts state that the Supreme Court’s finding that there was an unfair relationship in Johnson does not create a ‘broadly applicable precedent’.

While the Supreme Court stressed that unfairness turned on the facts of each case, the relationship it found to be unfair in Johnson was with FirstRand Bank’s London branch, and the FCA, on page 27 of Policy Statement PS26/3, describes its approach to designing its redress scheme as ‘anticipating what we consider a court would do on the facts of a section 140A CCA claim’. We find it notable that MotoNovo continues to play down the significance of a finding made in a case that bore its name.

What does this mean for MotoNovo customers?

MotoNovo doubling its redress charge does not, in itself, change whether you are owed compensation.

If MotoNovo provided your motor finance and you entered into an agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, your agreement may fall within the regulator’s redress scheme. MotoNovo’s own website details that it received over 164,000 complaints relating to both its older agreements and those provided by MotoNovo Finance Limited in the first six months of 2026 alone.

The FCA redress scheme is partially suspended while the four legal challenges against it are before the Upper Tribunal. Lenders must still notify you if you have complained and are not owed compensation, with the first deadlines falling on 18 November 2026 and 18 January 2027. If MotoNovo or another lender tells you that you are not eligible for redress, you may be able to challenge that decision.

Will my claim be affected if Aldermore is sold?

While a sale would change who owns MotoNovo Finance Limited, it would not, in itself, remove MotoNovo Finance Limited’s obligations to customers to whom it may owe redress. For agreements entered into before May 2019, these obligations appear to remain with FirstRand Bank.

When could I receive compensation?

The regulator has said that if the scheme is upheld and the judgment is not appealed, it expects payments to begin in 2027. If the scheme is overturned and it has to seek views on a revised version, compensation could be delayed until 2028 or beyond.

Register your motor finance claim with Harcus Parker

You do not need professional representation, such as a solicitor or a claims management company, to complain to your lender or to receive any compensation you are owed, and you can do so at no cost.

However, there are many reasons why you may choose to use a solicitor, and should you instruct us, we can:

  • identify all your historical motor finance agreements dating back to 6 April 2007, including whether a MotoNovo agreement was provided by FirstRand Bank or by MotoNovo Finance Limited;
  • request disclosure of the commission payable on your agreement and whether your agreement involved a DCA, a high commission, or a contractual tie;
  • review any decision that you are not owed compensation and challenge it where we believe it is wrong;
  • verify lender calculations if they determine you are owed redress and provide you with an offer; and
  • investigate whether you may have grounds to bring additional claims that fall outside the scheme.

Instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you have a valid claim and does not mean that you will receive more compensation than you would if you complained yourself.

Check your eligibility and register your car finance claim with Harcus Parker here.

We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.