Back
This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:
In Technical Annex 2: State of Competition in the Motor Finance Market, published by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) alongside its car finance redress scheme proposals on 7 October 2025, the regulator notes that personal contract purchase (PCP) finance is the most popular type of motor finance arrangement for new vehicles.
Finance & Leasing Association (FLA) data supports this, highlighting that motor finance arranged at the point of sale (i.e. at the dealership) accounted for over 80% of private new car sales in 2024.
While the structural features of PCP have not been the direct focus of the regulator’s investigation or the development of its redress scheme, they do help to explain why so many consumers entered into complex products in which lenders could charge hidden and excessive commissions.
PCP has long been marketed to motorists as a modern, flexible way to drive a newer, more expensive car while maintaining a seemingly affordable monthly payment. For many consumers, their PCP agreement has achieved precisely that. However, the structure that makes PCPs so attractive may also introduce hidden flaws and significant risks, many of which may not have been explained adequately at the point of sale.
PCP is a type of hire purchase (HP) agreement. In contrast to a traditional HP arrangement, rather than repaying the full cost of the car over the term of the agreement, the finance provider estimates what the vehicle will be worth at the end of the term and defers that figure into a larger final sum, the Guaranteed Minimum Future Value (GMFV) or ‘balloon payment.’
If you take out a PCP agreement, you will usually:
At the end of the term, you then have a choice between:
Under a traditional hire purchase agreement you repay the full cost of the vehicle across the term, and once the final payment and any option to purchase fee have been made, the car is yours. There is no mileage limit or penalty to worry about, and no end-of-term condition inspection, because you are buying the vehicle outright rather than handing it back.
A PCP agreement defers part of the price into the balloon payment, which is also why the mileage commitment and fair wear and tear assessments exist. The lender’s position at the end of a PCP agreement depends on what the car is worth, so the agreement has to control how you use it in the meantime.
Both fall within the scope of the FCA’s redress scheme.
Several factors have driven the growth and popularity of PCP:
While these factors all seem positive, the multi-part structure of PCP agreements often makes it difficult for consumers to calculate the total cost of credit, what they are actually paying for the vehicle, or to identify where their interest rate may have been inflated to incorporate a hidden commission payment.
Today, PCP has become closely associated with the UK’s car finance mis-selling scandal, with the FCA estimating that 12.1 million car finance agreements entered into between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, including but not exclusively PCP agreements, are eligible for compensation.
These structural features of PCP, combined with the way the product has been marketed, have helped drive its popularity and bring large numbers of consumers into complex arrangements in which mis-selling could occur at scale.
As you are financing only the expected depreciation and interest on your borrowing, rather than the full price of the vehicle, your monthly payments are usually lower than they would be under a hire purchase agreement for the same car. Using a car finance calculator on a dealer’s website will often demonstrate this clearly.
The opportunity to hand the car back, pay the balloon payment and own the vehicle outright, or 'part-exchange' the car and move into another PCP agreement, gives you options around what you wish to do.
However, in practice, many agreements do not reach full term, as your dealership will likely contact you to 'upgrade' sooner, selling it to you as a benefit while securing a valuable used car for their inventory, which they would then almost certainly look to sell via an HP arrangement.
The GMFV offers you some protection if your vehicle's real-world value at the end of the term is lower than the figure quoted when you entered into the agreement. You will usually be able to walk away by returning the car, subject to any contractual obligations or 'penalty' payments you may have to pay due to the vehicle's mileage and condition.
Fixed monthly payments, a defined term, and knowing what you will need to pay if you make your balloon payment may help you plan your household budget and transportation costs more effectively.
The problem with PCP is not that these benefits are illusory, but that they are often presented without equal emphasis on the potential drawbacks, leaving people in an environment where mis-selling through the addition of undisclosed and excessive commissions can occur.
The GMFV lies at the heart of your PCP agreement and will be estimated by the lender based on several factors, including the make and model of the vehicle, the term length, and the mileage you say you will do over the course of the term.
Your monthly repayment is calculated broadly as:
(Cash price of the car – GMFV – your deposit) + interest, spread over the term = your monthly payment
A higher GMFV relative to the car's cash price means the lender expects the vehicle to retain more of its value. That, in turn, means that:
This creates a clear commercial incentive for lenders to set optimistic residual values. As well as making PCP agreements appear cheaper, from the lender's and car dealer's perspectives, a higher GMFV helps support three- and four-year resale values, as the finance model depends on those values being achieved.
When you enter into a PCP agreement, the three options you will have at the end of the term are often presented with equal weight.
In practice, a high GMFV discourages you from ever making the balloon payment:
Ultimately, the outcome is that PCP often functions less as a route to vehicle ownership and more as a mechanism for dealers and lenders to keep you in a permanent cycle of monthly payments. While the high GMFV helps car dealers manage used vehicle supply and pricing, it may leave you always paying for cars you may never own.
Your mileage commitment is central to how your PCP agreement is priced; however, it is easy to underestimate or misunderstand its impact.
When you enter into a PCP agreement, you agree (usually by estimating) an annual mileage commitment, which is used to calculate your total mileage allowance over the term. For example, if you drive 10,000 miles a year and enter into a four-year PCP agreement, your total allowance will be 40,000 miles.
The higher the mileage:
Conversely, selecting a lower mileage allowance will usually reduce your monthly payment, because the lender assumes the car will be worth more at the end of the term.
Some car dealers encourage their customers to choose an unrealistically high mileage limit ‘to be safe.’ While that may appear prudent on the surface, in reality, it may mean that:
For example, if you regularly drive 7,000 miles per year but enter into a PCP agreement on the basis that you drive 12,000 miles per year to avoid the risk of excess charges, you are effectively paying every month for a benefit you never use. Over the course of your term, that additional cost can be significant.
The opposite problem arises if your car dealer steers you towards committing to a lower mileage limit to make the monthly payment appear more affordable. In some cases, your dealer may have even set the limit without asking you.
If you exceed your total mileage allowance and hand the vehicle back at the end of the term, you will usually have to pay an excess mileage charge, calculated in pence per mile. According to Carlingo, these charges can range anywhere from 7.2p to 25p per mile, often plus VAT.
To illustrate, if:
you could face a bill of £500 plus VAT for the mileage alone.
Many consumers only discover the real cost of their mileage decision when they have the car back and later receive an invoice, sometimes alongside charges for damage that is said to fall outside its ‘fair wear and tear’ parameters.
You typically enter into a PCP agreement for three or four years. However, there is usually no provision for what happens if life changes during that time. For example, you could move house, change jobs and face a longer commute, become a carer for a loved one, or have other changes in your family circumstances.
A rigid mileage structure and having to commit upfront can leave you trapped between paying more than necessary and risking a substantial bill at the end.
While the GMFV and mileage commitments are the most significant factors that can impact your monthly payment, there are several additional risks that you may not be aware of when you enter into the agreement.
If you want to settle your agreement early to change to a new vehicle, you may owe more than what the car is worth. In this situation, your negative equity may be rolled into a new agreement, leaving you paying interest on the shortfall as well as the cost of the new vehicle, and resulting in an inflated monthly repayment.
If you hand the car back, you may have to pay additional charges for anything deemed beyond 'fair wear and tear' by the person who inspects the vehicle. While industry bodies publish guidelines, and you should have received guidance on what constitutes fair wear and tear in your PCP welcome pack, the assessment can be highly subjective, and the level of scrutiny of your vehicle may surprise you.
The FCA’s car finance redress scheme is the culmination of several years of work, and specifically its investigation that it opened on 11 January 2024, into how hidden and excessive commissions and tied arrangements in car finance deals, including PCP, saw consumers pay billions more than they should have done during the term of their agreements.
While hidden and excessive commissions and tied arrangements are not exclusively associated with PCP agreements, the structuring of this type of finance may have enabled car finance brokers and dealers to engage in mis-selling on a significant scale.
In most cases, yes. However, the two routes work very differently, and one of them may be less useful than you might expect.
Section 99 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 gives you the right to end a regulated hire purchase or conditional sale agreement at any point before the final payment falls due, and most PCP agreements fall into this category. Section 100 then caps what you owe if you do terminate early, limiting your liability to half of the total price. If you have paid less than half, you pay the difference; if you have already paid at least half, you owe nothing further and can return the car, after which your agreement ends.
A common issue that arises with PCP is that the balloon payment counts towards the total price. As the balloon payment often accounts for a third or more of the total price, the halfway point on a PCP agreement often falls much later than you might assume it does, and is sometimes close to the end of the term. While voluntary termination is a genuine statutory right, the mechanics of PCP mean that it is often less practical or accessible than it sounds or is sold as.
Voluntary termination does not wipe out what you already owe, either. Any arrears and charges for damage beyond fair wear and tear remain payable.
Alternatively, you can ask your lender for a settlement figure at any time and pay off the agreement rather than returning the vehicle. That means you keep the vehicle, but the figure may be more than what the car is actually worth.
In this situation, your motor insurer will pay the vehicle’s market value at the time of the loss. Your finance balance is a different figure, and with a PCP agreement it can be considerably higher due to the balloon payment sitting inside the outstanding balance while the car’s value falls.
That difference is what GAP insurance is designed to cover, which is why it is so often sold alongside PCP. Whether there were issues with how your GAP insurance was sold is a separate question from those surrounding car finance mis-selling, which we have examined in detail.
Yes. The FCA’s redress scheme covers agreements entered into between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, and you can complain about your agreement irrespective of whether it has ended, is still running, or was settled early.
If your agreement is live, you should be aware that, under the regulator’s final rules, your lender can set off compensation against any arrears or defaults on the agreement the compensation relates to. That means that if you are behind on that agreement, any redress may reduce what you owe rather than reach you as a payment. You can also object to set-off if you dispute arrears or if you have arrears on priority debts that you could use your redress award to pay.
If your car dealer, acting as a broker, did not explain the potential drawbacks of PCP, this may, in some circumstances, have amounted to mis-selling, depending on the facts and the rules that applied at the time. However, the FCA’s focus has been on the charging of hidden or excessive commissions or the use of tied agreements that made your agreement more expensive than it should have been, not on the features of the product itself. Arguments about how the product was explained to you, which in some cases seem to us to be strong, fall outside the scheme and would need to be pursued separately.
You will not know if you are eligible to claim without first obtaining disclosure of what commissions, if any, and what type of commissions your dealership (or your car finance broker, if it was not your dealer) received from your lender.
The regulator's redress scheme means that you can bring your car finance claim yourself, and at no cost. However, there are several potential drawbacks to the scheme that may mean you do not get everything you are owed and other compelling reasons why you may wish to instruct a solicitor to manage your car finance claim on your behalf. You should, however, note that instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you will receive compensation or have a valid claim.
You can register your car finance mis-selling claim with Harcus Parker here.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.