Back
This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:
Eight motor finance lenders have urged the Court of Appeal to block mass lawsuits against alleged car finance mis-selling, according to a report in the Financial Times.
The lenders, which include Black Horse, the primary motor finance branch of Lloyds Banking Group, as well as the finance arms of Volkswagen, BMW, and Stellantis, want judges to prevent Manchester-based Barings Law from bringing group litigation, known as omnibus claims, on behalf of thousands of motorists.
The case, heard at the Court of Appeal on Wednesday, 22 April 2026, follows the High Court judgment in Angel & Ors v Black Horse Ltd & Ors, handed down on 4 March 2025, which ruled that almost 6,000 car finance mis-selling claimants could proceed using eight omnibus forms against the eight defendants in question. The outcome will determine whether these claimants can pursue their redress claims on this basis outside the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) redress scheme, which will proceed later in 2026, subject to any challenges brought against it.
Regardless of the outcome at the Court of Appeal, it is likely that the 'losing' side will seek to appeal the ruling at the Supreme Court.
These hearings are likely to prove significant, as the outcome could lead to many thousands more motor finance redress claims being pursued through litigation rather than the redress scheme. While lenders have long been setting aside provisions to cover anticipated liabilities from the scheme, it is unknown whether these also include potential compensation payments that may arise from litigation. Separately, many lenders have indicated their acceptance of the FCA's final redress rules and the scheme's structure.
The FT also reported that Patrick Goodall KC, acting for Black Horse and Close Brothers, had said in a written submission that each claim was ‘fact-specific’ and, therefore, not suitable to be resolved by the courts in bulk, and that motorists who wanted to pursue litigation could do so via the usual county court route.
This view was countered by the submission of David Cavender KC, representing the claimants, who wrote that the lenders' appeal was 'a blatant attempt to shut down what on any view are strong claims for compensation brought by approximately 5,000 individual consumers' and that issuing individual claims would force many claimants into the small claims track. This route would prevent claimants from recovering legal costs and may deter many from pursuing their claims outside the redress scheme, as it would be financially unviable to do so.
Mr Cavender KC added, ‘defendant banks know that if the claimants are not allowed to proceed on omnibus claim forms that a significant proportion of the claims will fall away.’
Days after the FCA published its redress scheme rules on 30 March 2026, the regulator’s chief executive Nikhil Rathi warned that consumers that pursue litigation run the risk of not receiving any redress at all, and also stated: ‘We think it is really unlikely that across the 12 million eligible agreements that we have identified as available for compensation that somehow the courts are going to award all of those higher compensation than in our scheme.’
Rathi's view contradicts that of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Fair Banking, which, in a November 2025 report, wrote that many consumers could receive double the regulator's initial estimated average of £700 in compensation per affected agreement. The FCA subsequently amended this estimate to £829 redress per agreement in its final rules.
Alongside the Court of Appeal hearing in Angel, it also recently emerged that advocacy group Consumer Voice will challenge certain aspects of the regulator’s redress scheme alongside Courmacs Legal.
After this news became public, the FCA issued a statement, without naming any parties directly, calling on law firms and claims management companies that are involved in a potential challenge against the scheme and have clients pursuing motor finance claims to ‘consider their position and that of their clients carefully’ due to the potential for a challenge to delay compensation payments.
However, even the potential for a delay to the start of the scheme is a point of contention, with Consumer Voice telling the BBC: ‘The [FCA compensation] scheme should still be able to get up and running, while the Tribunal looks urgently at the parts of the rules dealing with redress.
‘The aim is to fix the flaws, not to stop compensation.’
After the deadline for bringing a challenge to the scheme passed on Monday, 27 April, the FCA published another statement, saying it was ‘disappointing that some have decided to challenge it and delay customers getting their money back.’
While the FCA scheme faces legal challenges and potential delays, it is vital that consumers carefully consider all options.
In addition to potentially receiving a higher compensation award, some consumers may have grounds to bring additional claims, such as for mis-sold GAP insurance and irresponsible lending, depending on their circumstances and should an investigation show such a complaint may be viable.
Participating in an omnibus claim would not cover such instances, however, as the purpose of that process is to pursue and settle multiple claims at once where the same facts apply to each claim.
While the FCA’s motor finance redress scheme means you can complain and receive any compensation due without using a professional representative and without incurring any costs, there are many reasons why you may wish to instruct a solicitor to manage your motor finance claim.
In addition to investigating potential additional complaints, a solicitor can also verify your claim and lenders' redress calculations to ensure that you receive everything you should and that lenders have applied the redress scheme rules correctly. By handling cases on an individual basis rather than within mass litigation, we can ensure your unique circumstances are fully evaluated.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.