Back
This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:
Lloyds Banking Group will not seek to challenge the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) motor finance redress scheme, according to the Financial Times.
In a report published on Friday, 10 April, the FT wrote that the banking giant, which is the UK’s largest motor finance provider via its Black Horse brand, had, according to people familiar with the matter, ‘weighed mounting a legal challenge to the scheme because it believed that the regulator had not adhered to court judgments’.
The FT quoted a Lloyds spokesperson as saying: “While we remain disappointed in and disagree with [the FCA’s] conclusions, we believe that moving forward with the scheme is now the right step for our customers and shareholders in support of a clear, orderly and final process that provides certainty for consumers and industry.
“Motor finance continues to play a critical role for customers across the UK and our focus is on ensuring these essential services are provided.”
Lloyds has set aside a total of £1.95 billion to cover redress payments and the administration of the FCA scheme and has also recently disclosed that it does not believe it will need to make any further provisions.
However, accepting the scheme does not guarantee that Lloyds, or any other affected lender, will calculate individual compensation awards in a way that ensures consumers receive the correct amount of redress, which is why independent verification remains vital.
The FT reported on Lloyds' decision not to challenge the regulator's redress scheme days after FirstRand Bank and Close Brothers, the two lenders involved in the landmark Johnson, Wrench and Hopcraft test cases, which culminated in the 1 August 2025 Supreme Court ruling, both commented on the scheme.
FirstRand Bank, which provides vehicle finance in the UK under the MotoNovo brand, announced a significant increase in its redress scheme provision, describing the FCA scheme rules as ‘deeply flawed’ and saying it planned to exit the UK motor finance market. Such hostile rhetoric underscores the defensive and adversarial stance some lenders continue to take and is another example of why professional legal representation remains an attractive safeguard for consumers.
Meanwhile, Close Brothers has stated that it believes the redress scheme will cost £320 million, a slight increase on previously reported provisions of around £300 million. The lender has also disclosed that it expects compensation of around £500 on average to be due under approximately 720,000 of its agreements.
The rules of FCA redress programmes state that parties have up to 28 days from the date of a scheme announcement to bring a legal challenge. While Lloyds has been one of the most prominent voices in criticising the regulator since it began its investigation into historical misconduct in the motor finance sector on 11 January 2024, it remains possible that other lenders and trade associations may decide to challenge the rules. Law firms and consumer groups may also seek to take legal action against the FCA should they feel that aspects of the final rules overly favour lenders.
Jonathan Kirk KC, who acted for the intervening National Franchised Dealers Association during the Johnson, Wrench and Hopcraft Supreme Court hearings, warned during the redress scheme consultation period that a judicial review is ‘inevitable’. It is unknown whether Mr Kirk KC’s view has changed in light of the detail in the regulator’s final rules.
The FCA's redress scheme means you can complain and get any car finance compensation your lenders owe you at no cost, without using professional representation.
However, there are several reasons why you may wish to use a solicitor for your claim. Even if your lender does not challenge the broader scheme, you may still need expert assistance to scrutinise calculations and investigate whether you have grounds to complain about additional issues, such as GAP insurance mis-selling and irresponsible lending.
The regulator has reiterated that consumers with existing complaints will receive a response from their lender and a redress offer more quickly than those who wait for their lender to contact them.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.