Back

Car finance cost
12 March 2026

How will I know if my car finance was mis-sold?

Important update: The FCA redress scheme is partially suspended

This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:

  • The redress scheme is partially suspended: The Upper Tribunal will hear four challenges to the scheme between 16 February and 3 March 2027. Lenders are not currently required to calculate or pay redress, and payments are not expected to begin until 2027 at the earliest. Your lender should write to you if you have already complained and you are not owed compensation, although the FCA says some consumers may not be told until the legal process concludes.
  • Revised eligibility estimate: The FCA now estimates that 12.1 million agreements are eligible for compensation, down from the 14.2 million estimated in its 2025 consultation.
  • Increased compensation estimate: The FCA now anticipates average redress payouts of £829 per mis-sold agreement.
  • Compensatory interest changes: The regulator has introduced a minimum 3% floor for compensatory interest; however, the rate applied to awards within the redress scheme can no longer be challenged.
  • You may not hear from your lender: If the scheme proceeds, contact obligations also cover certain consumers who have not complained, including those potentially owed compensation and certain time-barred cases. If you do not hear from your lender, you could still have a valid claim but risk missing out entirely.

Most people judge a car finance deal by whether the monthly payment felt affordable when they entered into it. 

The Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) motor finance work examined disclosure of commission, conflicts of interest and dealer-lender relationships at the point of sale. The FCA confirmed its final redress rules on 30 March 2026; the scheme is currently partially suspended while four legal challenges are considered.

If you entered into an eligible car finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, inadequate disclosure of certain commission arrangements or contractual ties may entitle you to compensation. The FCA’s final estimated average is £829 per eligible agreement, including interest. An individual award may be higher or lower, and eligibility depends on the rules and the facts.

Can you remember what happened at the dealership?

You may be in scope and eligible to receive compensation via the regulator’s redress scheme if any of the following happened when buying and financing your vehicle:

  • You were not told the lender would pay the dealer a commission, or the dealer told you in vague wording that did not explain the incentive properly.
  • Your interest rate felt 'flexible' or negotiable, but it was not explained why.
  • Your dealer did not tell you that they had access only to one lender or a limited panel, or that it was tied to a particular lender or incentivised to get you to take finance with a specific lender.
  • The dealer presented the monthly payment as the only or primary material factor, with little clarity on the total cost of credit, how the interest rate was set, or whether cheaper options were available.
  • You left with paperwork, but it did not clearly disclose commissions or conflicts of interest in a way you could reasonably have been expected to see, discover, or understand.

None of these points proves mis-selling on its own. However, they are practical indicators of the disclosure gaps that the FCA's final redress scheme is designed to address. 

What ‘mis-sold’ means in the context of the FCA’s final redress rules

The FCA’s final redress rules focus on: 

  • commission structures and conflicts of interest within the sale of motor finance products and whether these were adequately disclosed; and
  • whether contractual ties between dealers and lenders distorted the transaction in ways that the customer could not see or reasonably have become aware of.

The relevant arrangements are listed below. Their presence does not automatically guarantee compensation: the rules also address adequate disclosure, minimum commission amounts, no-interest agreements, time limits, previously resolved claims and other exceptions and exclusions.

  • Discretionary commission arrangements (DCAs), which allowed car dealers to influence the interest rate paid and thereby increase their commissions. The FCA banned DCAs on 28 January 2021.
  • High commission arrangements, where commission was at least 39% of the total cost of credit and at least 10% of the loan amount under the final scheme rules.
  • Contractual ties giving a lender exclusivity or a right of first refusal, subject to the rules and the exception for visible links between the lender, manufacturer and franchised dealer.

What should have happened at the dealership (and what often went wrong)

If the sales process had been fair, any incentives the car dealer had to offer you a specific interest rate or place you with a specific lender would have been visible. If dealers did not disclose those incentives, you could not judge properly whether a dealer was recommending or providing you with a product because it was the best one to suit your circumstances, or because it was the one that would pay them the most commission.

1. All incentives and conflicts should have been clear

In a fair process, you would understand clearly that:

  • the dealer is acting as a broker in arranging your car finance;
  • the lender may pay the dealer; and
  • the structure of the agreement may create incentives that influence what you are offered.

The alleged misconduct in motor finance arose when disclosure was either absent, buried in small print, or too vague to be meaningful, particularly when a commission payment could change depending on the terms and interest rate in the agreement.

2. The rate-setting process should have been clear, not implied

A common red flag that could indicate that mis-selling occurred is that your dealer told you that your rate was 'what the system is giving you,' when the commercial reality may have been that your rate could move and that the dealer's earnings could move with it. The regulator's investigations and final redress rules relating to car finance agreements with undisclosed DCAs sit in that space.

3. Tied relationships should not have been invisible

If your dealership was effectively tied to one specific lender, or operated under arrangements that steered consumers to a particular lender, it was not a fair process if your dealer led you to assume, or told you, that you had a range of options across a genuinely competitive market when you did not.

4. Conversations should not have centred on the monthly payment

Conversations about motor finance at the dealership often start and end with ‘how much can you afford per month?' While this does not automatically signify mis-selling, if the focus on the monthly payment occurred alongside non-disclosure of commission or conflicts of interest, it becomes part of the overall misconduct that the FCA’s final redress rules are aiming to remedy at scale.

Can I determine whether I was mis-sold?

In general, financial mis-selling can be challenging to identify and difficult to prove. In a motor finance context, your monthly payment does not, on its own, show whether mis-selling occurred, and mis-selling can be difficult to identify without documents and lender disclosure. However, there are some things that you may be able to consider that could indicate whether your car finance agreements were mis-sold and whether you may be eligible for compensation.

Review your documents

If you still have them, review:

  • your credit agreement;
  • any pre-contract information supplied by your broker or lender;
  • your car finance quotation; and
  • any dealer ‘addendum’ pages. 

You are specifically looking for wording that addresses:

  • whether the dealer receives commission from the lender;
  • the mechanism by which any commission was determined;
  • whether commission varies depending on the interest rate or finance terms; and
  • whether the dealer selected an agreement from a panel of lenders or was restricted or tied to a particular lender.

Discover how to find your old car finance agreements.

Do not worry about what you may or may not remember

In many cases, disclosure was entirely non-existent or provided in a vague manner that is unlikely to have registered at the time of the sale. That is why the document trail, what your dealer provided to you in writing, and how they provided it matter. The FCA's redress scheme is designed to operate at scale, and decisions will be evidence-driven. Your documents may be even more vital if you choose not to participate in the redress scheme because you believe you may be able to achieve a more significant compensation award via litigation.

Treat any finance add-ons as a separate line item

The regulator's final redress scheme will handle complaints arising from undisclosed commissions or contractual ties in your motor finance agreement. However, there may also have been disclosure issues regarding commissions on common add-on products, such as GAP insurance and cosmetic cover. 

While these additional products will not be covered in the FCA redress scheme, instructing a solicitor to manage your car finance complaint means they can investigate whether you have grounds to bring these additional claims. A solicitor can also advise on the implications of accepting any redress offer, including whether it may affect separate complaints about add-ons, and investigate whether you experienced consequential loss due to motor finance mis-selling.

What you can do now

You can complain directly to your lender for free, without using a solicitor. The FCA encourages consumers who think they may have been affected to complain now. During the partial suspension, lenders are not required to calculate or pay scheme redress, although certain response and preparation duties continue. Scheme payments are not expected before 2027.

If you wish to complain yourself, contact your lender with the information you have so it can identify your agreements and assess your complaint. Our FAQs explain the current response deadlines and exceptions. You do not need to make a duplicate complaint if you have already complained about the same matter.

Or we can help you

Due to the lender-led nature of the final redress scheme, you may still want help with your complaint, particularly if your motor finance agreement ended more than six years ago and there is an increased risk that your lender no longer holds your records.

Harcus Parker can help identify historical agreements, review lender decisions and consider whether there are separate issues elsewhere in the transaction. You can register your claim here.

We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.