Back
This article was written before recent developments around the FCA’s redress scheme. If you entered into a motor finance agreement between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, please note the following:
According to a report published in The Times on 22 September 2026, BMW’s British motor finance arm has increased its car finance redress provision to £611.6 million.
The figure represents an increase of more than £400 million in 2025, with the business previously setting aside about £207 million in 2024, while the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) continued to investigate historical misconduct in the motor finance sector. The Times, citing BMW Financial Services (GB) Limited accounts filed at Companies House and made public on 21 September 2026, also reported that the carmaker has earmarked a further £25.5 million on top of this provision to cover agreements that fall outside of the FCA’s redress scheme but where it considers there remains a risk of complaints and legal claims.
As has become standard with lenders announcing motor finance redress provisions, BMW cautioned that its final car finance compensation costs could be ‘materially different’.
BMW’s £611.6 million provision is among the most significant disclosed by lenders. Other notable lenders to have provisioned include:
We previously explored provisions made by these and other firms in our analysis of which lenders were involved in car finance mis-selling.
This is part of the overall motor finance redress picture that we believe deserves more attention.
Four parties are challenging the redress scheme at the Upper Tribunal: the advocacy group Consumer Voice, and three lenders, with Volkswagen Financial Services and CA Auto Finance UK joining Mercedes-Benz. Of the three lenders challenging, Mercedes-Benz and Volkswagen Financial Services have publicly disclosed provisions, of £424 million and £725 million respectively.
Volkswagen Financial Services’ provision is larger than Mercedes-Benz’s, but the largest disclosed provisions still sit with lenders that chose not to challenge the scheme. Several lenders, including BMW, Lloyds Banking Group, Close Brothers and Santander, confirmed ahead of the deadline for challenging the final redress rules published in Policy Statement PS26/3 that they would not challenge the scheme. That was a particularly notable move for Lloyds and Santander, two of the regulator’s most frequent critics throughout its motor finance investigations.
It is of course open to any firm to take a view on the lawfulness of the rules that affect it, and none of this tells us anything about the merits of the challenges, which are for the Upper Tribunal to decide. But it does, in our view, somewhat undercut the suggestion that the scheme is so unworkable or so disproportionate that lenders cannot live with it. The firms with the largest liabilities have chosen not to contest the rules that mean they will have to pay.
A provision is an accounting judgement about a cost a company considers probable. It is not an admission of liability, and lenders are careful to say so.
It is, however, a reasonable indication of what a lender privately expects to pay. BMW has almost tripled its provision in a single year, from about £207 million to £611.6 million. This same pattern has repeated across lenders since firms first began publicly provisioning for motor finance redress.
We made a similar observation in our analysis of what motor finance claimants can learn from PPI. During that particular scandal, Lloyds set aside £3.2 billion in May 2011, before the industry had formally abandoned its legal challenge to the regulator’s PPI complaint handling rules, and while it was still contesting individual cases. Redress payments then continued for another eight years.
Not directly. The FCA’s redress scheme remains partially suspended, and the Upper Tribunal will hear the four challenges between 16 and 26 February 2027. The regulator does not expect redress payments to begin before 2027 and has cautioned that if the scheme is quashed and it consults on a replacement, any new scheme could face similar challenges and push payments out to 2028 or beyond. It has also noted that a ruling upholding the scheme could itself be appealed.
What BMW’s accounts do indicate, however, is that it has reserved the money and expects to pay compensation.
No. A provision is a lender’s own estimate of what the scheme is likely to cost it in total, covering both the redress it expects to pay and the cost of administering claims. Whether an individual agreement is eligible for redress depends on whether it contained one of the three commission arrangements the scheme covers. If you complain to your lender, your lender will assess your complaint and eligibility against the final rules. If you do not complain, your lender will assess your agreement and, if it can identify you, will write to you if it believes it may owe you money.
No. Redress will be calculated per agreement under the scheme rules, not based on what a lender has set aside. The lenders with larger provisions are generally those who provided motor finance to the greatest number of consumers, which is why they expect to face more significant liabilities. We have set out how redress will be calculated and the factors that may influence your award here.
No. The hearing dates have since been confirmed as 16 to 26 February 2027, and the FCA’s guidance that payments are unlikely to begin before 2027 remains unchanged.
You do not need professional representation to complain to your lender or to receive any compensation you are owed, and you can do so at no cost.
If you choose to instruct us to manage your motor finance claim, we can:
Instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you will receive compensation or that you have a valid claim.
You can check your eligibility and register your car finance mis-selling claim here.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.