Back
According to a report published by The Times on 7 October 2026, Volkswagen Financial Services (UK) Limited (VWFS) has set aside £725 million to cover the cost of motor finance redress in its accounts for the year ending 31 December 2025, which were filed at Companies House on 6 October 2026.
VWFS, which describes itself in its grounds of challenge to the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) motor finance scheme as ‘the largest captive lender in the UK motor finance market’, meaning the largest lender owned by a vehicle manufacturer, is one of the three lenders challenging the scheme at the Upper Tribunal, alongside Mercedes-Benz Financial Services and CA Auto Finance UK (CAAF).
In its accounts, VWFS says it calculated its provision using the criteria in Policy Statement PS26/3, but that the rules ‘do not reflect the specific elements of, or provide sufficient clarity on, how the scheme applies to a captive finance provider’, according to City AM reporting. The publication also reported VWFS as writing in its accounts that ‘the VW group supports redress for customers who were genuinely disadvantaged but has identified several issues that the VW group believe require independent consideration, including how the redress scheme applies in a captive lender model, where in some cases customers paid less because their finance was supported by one of the VW group brand partners’.
VWFS has paid redress to its customers in the recent past. In October 2024, the regulator fined the company £5.4 million for failing to treat customers in financial difficulty fairly between 2017 and 2023, and VWFS agreed to pay more than £21.5 million in redress to around 110,000 customers.
In grounds of challenge dated 27 April 2026, which the FCA has published, VWFS says that it ‘strongly supports the introduction of a consumer redress scheme’ for motor finance agreements, but that ‘it is essential that any such scheme is lawful’. The lender argues that the regulator’s scheme is not lawful, on four grounds.
VWFS argues that the FCA has no power to make rules covering agreements entered into before 1 April 2014, which is the date the regulator took over consumer credit regulation, and so Scheme 1, covering agreements entered into from 6 April 2007 to 31 March 2014, is unlawful.
The lender says that the scheme wrongly requires lenders to presume an unfair relationship wherever a discretionary commission arrangement (DCA), high commission, or contractual tie was not adequately disclosed. VWFS calls the high commission thresholds, which the regulator has set at 39% or more of the total cost of credit and 10% or more of the loan, ‘arbitrary’ and argues that ties ‘do not typically cause harm to consumers and instead often give rise to consumer benefits’, calling these circumstances ‘inappropriate or excessively broad’.
VWFS argues that ‘the FCA has no power to require firms to presume causation of loss in a consumer redress scheme’ and that ‘a presumption of causation of loss would not be a matter that a court or tribunal would take into account for the purpose of determining whether a relevant failure caused loss or damage to consumers’.
Finally, the lender argues that redress under the scheme is not ‘rationally or reasonably linked’ to consumers’ actual losses and that, ‘instead, it is designed to give the consumer a windfall’.
The merits of each of these arguments are for the Upper Tribunal to decide. We do, however, find it difficult to square the description of a windfall with the FCA’s figures, which estimate that the average payment per eligible agreement will be £829 and that redress will be capped in one in three cases. If Volkswagen succeeds in its challenge on the first of its grounds, consumers with agreements they entered into before 1 April 2014, with any lender, could lose the redress scheme as a route to compensation for those agreements.
VWFS is the latest captive lender to disclose a provision.
That makes Volkswagen’s the largest known provision of any captive lender, and the third-largest overall, behind only Lloyds Banking Group’s £1.95 billion and FirstRand’s £750 million.
Captive lenders were among those who benefitted from changes made between Consultation Paper CP25/27 and the FCA’s final rules. Under the final rules, a contractual tie alone will not qualify an agreement for redress if there were demonstrably visible links between the lender, the manufacturer and the franchised dealer, such as a shared or similar name, and zero-APR agreements are not eligible for redress. We examined how those changes were expected to ease the burden on captive lenders before the regulator published PS26/3.
In our analysis of BMW’s recent hike in its provision, we noted that the lenders challenging the scheme were generally not the ones most exposed to it. VWFS’s provision complicates that picture, although the two largest disclosed provisions, those of Lloyds Banking Group and FirstRand, still sit with lenders that chose not to challenge the scheme.
The FCA’s list of lenders shows that VWFS has or had 65 trading names, including Audi Finance, Skoda Finance, Seat Finance, CUPRA Financial Services, Porsche Finance and Bentley Finance. If your agreement was with one of these, your lender is VWFS. If you are not sure who your lender was, the regulator explains how to find out.
As VWFS is one of the lenders challenging the FCA redress scheme, the regulator expects it to contact its complainants directly to explain the challenge, the partial suspension of the scheme and the resulting delay to compensation payments. Like all other lenders, VWFS is not required to calculate or pay any redress under the scheme until the legal process concludes. It must still tell complainants who are not owed compensation by 18 November 2026, if the agreement in question began on or after 1 April 2014 and the complaint was made by 30 June 2026, or by 18 January 2027, if the agreement began before 1 April 2014 and the complaint was made by 31 August 2026. If you complain after those dates and are not owed compensation, your lender should tell you within five months.
These deadlines do not apply if your lender considers your complaint to be out of time, or if your complaint concerns a contractual tie and the lender relies on the exception in PS26/3 for visible links between the lender, manufacturer and franchised dealer. Both are among the issues the Upper Tribunal will decide. If your lender tells you that you are not owed compensation, you can ask your lender to review its decision and, if you remain unhappy, can refer your complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). We previously examined what you should do if your lender says you are not owed compensation.
Days before VWFS’s provision became public, The Times reported that the motor finance arm of Stellantis, whose finance trading names include Vauxhall Finance, Peugeot Financial Services and Citroen Financial Services, had increased its provision, from £37.1 million at the beginning of 2025 to £221.3 million at year-end.
The Times reported that the company’s accounts say ‘significant uncertainty remains regarding the ultimate cost’ and that ‘actual outcomes may differ materially from the amount provided’. The newspaper added that Stellantis declined to comment.
On the same day that The Times reported VWFS’s provision, City AM reported that the FCA had been accused by the lender of refusing to share the economic modelling behind its redress scheme. The publication reported VWFS lawyers as saying: ‘It might have been expected that the FCA would accept – even welcome – scrutiny of all its workings such that lenders and consumers alike could be satisfied that its schemes are lawful and properly grounded. The FCA has adopted the opposite stance…that position is quite extraordinary, and unjustified’ and that the regulator’s wish to ‘shield its analysis from proper scrutiny is a serious cause for concern’.
Counsel for the FCA responded that ‘the overall impression created by the totality of these disclosure requests is that Volkswagen and CAAF are simply hoping something will turn up’.
In the same report, City AM noted that Consumer Voice, the fourth and sole non-lender challenger to the scheme, had accused the regulator of placing ‘excessive reliance on the interests of lenders’ that was ‘fortified by the [Treasury’s] growth agenda’. City AM further reported Consumer Voice’s lawyers as saying: ‘There is no suggestion (or reason to believe) that other stakeholders [than the Treasury] were able to enter into preliminary discussions with the FCA, make in-principle decisions, communicate house views or requests, receive and comment upon draft versions of the Consultation Paper and Policy Statement or attend deep dive Teams meetings with senior officials’.
Consumer Voice has previously alleged that the Treasury had sought to cap payouts at a level lenders could absorb, which we covered in our analysis of FCA chief executive Nikhil Rathi’s alleged threats to the consumer group over the redress scheme.
City AM reported a Treasury spokesperson as saying: ‘The FCA is operationally independent of government. Access to affordable motor finance is important for consumers, and we want to see certainty for consumers and firms so that this long running issue can be resolved in an orderly way’.
Following a case management hearing on 5 and 6 October 2026, after which it was decided that the Upper Tribunal would hear the challenges to the redress scheme from 16 February 2027, it was confirmed that the FCA must provide various datasets and its analyses of the impact of the DCA model and of the ban on DCAs, including the computer code or scripts underlying its matching methodology.
Further directions dated 26 October 2026, made after a video case management hearing on 23 October 2026, list the hearing for 12 days from 16 February 2027 (with the FCA confirming the same day that the challenges would be heard between that date and 3 March 2027) and require VWFS and CA Auto Finance UK to serve their expert evidence by 27 November 2026.
It is one of four challenges to the FCA’s redress scheme. All of them together led to the scheme’s partial suspension. The Irish News reported Consumer Voice’s Alex Neill as saying that ‘the FCA and lender applicants blame each other for the delay’, and that the FCA ‘blames the lenders’ requests for extensive disclosure of underlying data and reliance upon fresh expert evidence as the cause of the trial being pushed into next year’.
Not necessarily. If the regulator’s scheme is overturned in whole or in part, the FCA has said it may tell lenders to resolve complaints individually under the usual complaints process, meaning they would have to provide a final response within eight weeks and consumers would be able to escalate to the FOS or via the courts if they were dissatisfied with their lender’s response. The regulator has also warned that consulting on a replacement scheme could delay compensation until 2028 or beyond, were that also to be challenged.
You do not need professional representation, such as a solicitor or a claims management company, to complain to your lender about motor finance commission or to receive any compensation you are owed, and you can do so at no cost.
If you choose to instruct us to manage your car finance claim, we can:
Instructing a solicitor does not guarantee that you will receive more compensation or that you have a valid claim.
You can check your eligibility and register your car finance claim with Harcus Parker here.
We would be very happy to discuss any other questions you might have. You can call us on 0203 070 2822 to speak to a member of the team or email info@motorfinance.harcusparker.co.uk and someone will get back to you.